Collective Rights and the Cultural Identity of the Roma

Is the use of mechanisms that only focus on the protection of individual human rights sufficient to protect the cultural identity of minorities? Much more can be achieved by adopting a system that applies the principles of equality and non-discrimination, and encompasses the recognition of a collective right to cultural identity. Culture and cultural identity are indeed important for the identification of groups and ethnicity. But are the Roma an ethnic group? Are they a minority? In answering these questions, Italy is used as a case study to illustrate the limits of non-discrimination provisions and the need to recognise the collective right to cultural identity.

Review:

Die Untersuchung zeigt auf interessante Weise nicht nur die im Hinblick auf die Roma als Minderheit gegenwartig bestehenden Probleme, sondern auch wie diesen rechtlich begegnet werden kann. Sabine Scharnagl, Newsletter Menschenrechte, 3/2013-Literatur, pp. 223-224, OEsterreichisches Institut fur Menschenrechte.